Titlemax lawsuit

Data Breach Class Action Lawsuits and Settlements Overview: Who: A number of class action lawsuits and settlements have occurred recently revolving around claims related to data breaches and privacy. Why: Consumers will often claim, among other things, that a business failed to protect their personal and private information following a data breach.

Titlemax lawsuit. Mr. Jason Couch, Manager. Additional Contact Information. Phone Numbers. (256) 891-4647. Other Phone. Read More Business Details and See Alerts.

Defendant is ordered to provide Plaintiffs with a redacted copy of PRIV001 on or before October 23, 2015. SIGNED on October 9, 2015. Read Cantu v. Titlemax, Inc., 5:14-CV-628 RP, see flags on bad law, and search Casetext's comprehensive legal database.

TitleMax car and motorcycle title loans are available in 17 states. Unlike many other loan options, you don’t need a good credit score or a bank account to qualify for a title loan.TitleMax has 1342 locations, ... The Complaints and Customer Reviews shown on this profile include all complaints and reviews submitted about either the business headquarters or any of its ...To illustrate how these loans work, assume you own a car worth $5,000, and you find yourself in an emergency and need $1,000. A title loan lets you borrow against your vehicle so you can get the ...96 complaints closed in last 3 years. 14 complaints closed in last 12 months. All complaints are handled by the BBB where the company is Headquartered or a central customer complaint processing ...TitleMax strives to offer rates that are much lower than the industry standard, while providing a superior level of customer service. TitleMax not only offers a simple way to get the money you need when you need it, but we also pride ourselves on providing excellent customer service and a very easy loan process.TitleMax, TitleBucks and InstaLoan suffered a data breach affecting nearly 5 million people. Learn what information was compromised, how to protect yourself and …Reviews. 4.7 3,678 reviews. Get Pricing. Updated: 04/30/2024. Our promise. We provide a buying advantage with verified reviews and unbiased editorial research. 4.7. 5 80%. 4 11%.Posted on Jan 31, 2023. If you surrender the car, then you have fully complied with the pawn transaction. You don't owe any amount (there is no personal liability - even if you missed payments while you had the car), and you shouldn't be sued. If any title pawn employ tells you that you are going to be sued, or that you have to keep the car and ...

TitleMax of Texas Inc, NCP Finance Limited Partnership and Ivy Funding Company LLC: Defendant: City of Dallas: Case Number: 3:2021cv01040: Filed: May 7, 2021: Court: US District Court for the Northern District of Texas: Presiding Judge: A Joe Fish: Referring Judge: David L Horan: 2 Judge: Karen Gren Scholer: Nature of Suit: Civil Rights: Other ...The class action lawsuit was filed on March 31, the same day TitleMax announced the data breach. It alleges the victims' personal information was compromised due to TMX's "negligent and/or careless acts and omissions." Additionally, the suit alleges that TMX failed to warn its customers they were at increased risk of identity theft and fraud by waiting more than three months after the ...TitleMax of South Carolina, Inc. D/B/A TitleMax 15 Bull Street, Suite 200 Savannah, GA 31401 • Threaten use of force, violence or criminal prosecution against you. • Contact you at work if you or your boss told them . in writing. not to do so. • Communicate with you before 8:00 am orCar Title Loan Lawsuit; Car Wrecks. Serious Accidents; Dangerous Drugs & Devices. Hip Lawsuits. Metal on Metal Hip; IVC Filters; Mesothelioma-Asbestos Lawsuits; ... Title Loan Commercial April 9, 2019. Title Loans October 29, 2018. Essure Lawsuit Update September 18, 2018. Essure Lawsuits are Being Filed Against Bayer IndustriesInitial Titlemax / TMX Finance complaints should be directed to their team directly. You can find contact details for Titlemax / TMX Finance above. ComplaintsBoard.com is an independent complaint resolution platform that has been successfully voicing consumer concerns since 2004. We are doing work that matters - connecting customers with ...Accordingly, the Court finds no error, and ACCEPTS the Findings, Conclusions, and Recommendation of the United States Magistrate Judge. Plaintiffs TitleMax of Texas, Inc., Ivy Funding Company LLC, and NCP Finance Limited Partnership's motion for a preliminary injunction under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 65 [ECF. No. 11] is therefore DENIED.Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER signed by JUDGE LORETTA C. BIGGS on 5/9/2023; that Plaintiff Marcus Spellman's Motion to Enforce Award and Enter Judgment, (ECF No. 321 ), is GRANTED. FURTHER ORDERED that Defendant TitleMax of South Carolina, Inc., is ORDERED to pay to Plaintiff Marcus Spellman damages of $10,483.95 as set forth in the Arbitrator's Final Award, (ECF No. 321 -1 ...

Title loan contracts obligate borrowers to settle disputes through confidential arbitration hearings. This has stymied dozens of lawsuits accusing lenders of a range of deceptive tactics and kept judges from interpreting consumer protection laws in a court of law.TitleMax Titlemax, Pulaski, TN About 5 months ago I got a loan from Title Max for $1.100.00, I have been paying over $200.00 per month.They mailed me this summury claiming I owe $1.343.00. I called them and said I have been paying you about $220.00 per month how can I owe you that much money.The 39-page TitleMax lawsuit alleges that the defendant and parent company TMX Finance have violated the Military Lending Act ... Per the case, the plaintiff received a $2,518 vehicle title loan from TitleMax in September 2021, followed by a second loan of $1,318 in July 2022. The filing alleges that both loans had interest rates of over 100 ...The Supreme Court of Georgia on Monday trimmed an injunction against TitleMax in a suit accusing the title loan company of stealing competitor Drummond Financial Services LLC's customers ...22. The Southern District of Georgia has personal jurisdiction over Defendant because it conducts substantial business in Georgia and this District and collected and/or stored the PII of Plaintiff and Class Members in this District. Case 4:23-cv-00076-WTM-CLR Document 1 Filed 03/31/23 Page 6 of 51. 7.Published: Sep. 24, 2015 at 5:02 PM PDT | Updated: Sep. 24, 2015 at 8:13 PM PDT. Amarillo, TX - A class action lawsuit against TitleMax of Texas involves two local cases, which claim the business ...

Largest employers in hawaii.

You won’t owe us a dime for our services. We have settled thousands of debt collection harassment cases, and we’re prepared to help you, too. Contact Mike Agruss Law at 888-572-0176 to stop the harassment once and for all. Claim Free Consultation.3310 Mansfield HWY, Forest Hill, TX 76119. Email this Business. Headquarters. 5165 Emerald Pkwy Ste 100, Dublin, OH 43017-1063. BBB File Opened: 7/11/2023. Years in Business: 37. Business Started:TitleMax of Texas Inc, NCP Finance Limited Partnership and Ivy Funding Company LLC: Defendant: City of Dallas: Case Number: 3:2021cv01040: Filed: May 7, 2021: Court: US District Court for the Northern District of Texas: Presiding Judge: A Joe Fish: Referring Judge: David L Horan: 2 Judge: Karen Gren Scholer: Nature of Suit: Civil Rights: Other ...After hearing the parties' arguments, the trial court granted the City's plea and dismissed TitleMax's lawsuit. TitleMax timely filed the instant appeal. While this appeal was pending, the Texas Supreme Court decided the case of Texas Propane Gas Association v. City of Houston, No. 19-0767, 2021 Tex. LEXIS 302, at *21 (Tex. Apr. 16, 2021).TitleMax waived its right to forfeiture under a title pawn transaction when it failed to object to treatment of the loan as a secured debt prior to confirmation of the debtor's plan. TitleMax of Alabama v. Deakle, No. 20-335 (S.D. Ala. March 31, 2021). Prior to filing for bankruptcy, the debtor entered into a title pawn transaction with TitleMax.The Bureau found that TitleMax, a title loan company, extended loans to covered borrowers in violation of the Military Lending Act and the Consumer Financial …

If you received a breach notification letter from TMX Finance Corporate Services, Inc., TMX Finance LLC, TitleMax, TitleBucks, or InstaLoan: We would like to speak with you about your rights and potential legal remedies in response to this data breach. Please fill out the form, below, or contact us at (608) 237-1775 or [email protected]. Michael Falligant, as next friend of Michelle McElroy, who Falligant alleged was an incapacitated person, filed an action against TitleMax of Alabama, Inc. ("TitleMax"), alleging that TitleMax wrongfully repossessed and sold McElroy's vehicle. TitleMax filed a motion to compel arbitration of Falligant's claims, which the circuit court denied. TitleMax appealed. After review, the Alabama ... August 15, 2016 - 3:43 pm. Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook. A Nevada judge has delivered a blow to TitleMax, ordering an estimated 6,140 contracts to be voided with principal and ...For complaints regarding a Consumer Loan ("Personal Loan" or "Title Loan") or a Deferred Presentment Transaction ("Payday Loan") please file with the South Carolina Department of Consumer Affairs. For complaints regarding a credit card or mortgage loan through a Bank , please file with the federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau .2780 S Pacific Ave Ste B, Yuma, AZ 85365-3577. Email this Business. Headquarters. 5165 Emerald Pkwy Ste 100, Dublin, OH 43017-1063. BBB File Opened: 3/6/2020. Years in Business: 37. Business Started:TitleMax of Ohio, Inc. has 1 ... The Complaints and Customer Reviews shown on this profile include all complaints and reviews submitted about either the business headquarters or any of its ...On the third payment TitleMax requires that you pay at least 5% of the principal balance. For example, if you pawn your car for $1,000.00 your first two payments will be 129. Xx each a total of 258.The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau ("CFPB"), a federal agency that does the important work of monitoring businesses that prey on consumers and enforcing consumer-protection laws against companies that break them, recently announced a $10 million fine against the company commonly known as TitleMax (CFPB Action Against TitleMax).The primary thrust of the CFPB's action against ...McClairne filed this lawsuit against TitleMax on September 23, 2022, asserting a variety of claims including fraud, breach of contract, and violations of unspecified consumer rights. (Dkt. No. 1 at ¶ 5.1). McClairne amended his complaint on November 4, 2022, (Dkt. No. 9), and TitleMax moved to enforce the arbitration clause contained in the ...The class action lawsuit was filed on March 31, the same day TitleMax announced the data breach. It alleges the victims' personal information was compromised due to TMX's "negligent and/or ...Initial Titlemax / TMX Finance complaints should be directed to their team directly. You can find contact details for Titlemax / TMX Finance above. ComplaintsBoard.com is an independent complaint resolution platform that has been successfully voicing consumer concerns since 2004. We are doing work that matters - connecting customers with ...

4. TitleMax is a privately held company that is headquartered in Savannah, Georgia. During the Relevant Period, TitleMax operated using the trade names TitleMax, InstaLoan, and TitleBucks in 20 states with more than 1,000 stores. TitleMax primarily offers automobile title loans although it has a limited number of unsecured loan options.

The class action lawsuit was filed on March 31, the same day TitleMax announced the data breach. It alleges the victims' personal information was compromised due to TMX's "negligent and/or ...On February 23, 2023, the Bureau issued an order against TitleMax parent company TMX Finance LLC, which extends consumer loans that are secured by the title to the borrower’s car.On 07/29/2021 TitleMax of South Carolina Inc filed a Bankruptcy - Other Bankruptcy lawsuit against Harris. This case was filed in U.S. District Courts, South Carolina District Court. The Judge overseeing this case is Timothy M Cain. The case status is Pending - Other Pending. Case Details Parties Documents Dockets.According to National Lawyer Search, a civil warrant is one of two kinds of warrants usually used in a civil lawsuit regarding matters such as repossessing property or monetary rel...Fire at Airbnb rental forced woman to climb out window, suit alleges. By Record staff reports | 26 days ago. HOUSTON - A lawsuit seeking more than $1 million in damages is alleging a woman was forced to exit through a second-story window because the Airbnb she was staying at caught fire.Are you a North Carolina Resident that went out of state to get a Car Title Loan from TitleMax, LoanMax, First Capital, AutoMoney, Fast Auto, North American, or ...Car Title Loan Lawsuits Attorneys are now investigating lawsuits against predatory lenders across the United States, but especially in Utah and New Mexico. In some states, title loans are illegal ...The W. Commerce Street TitleMax store provides residents of the San Antonio area with title loans and personal loans. We are located just in front of the Peter Piper Pizza and right next to T-Mobile. If you live in or around the greater San Antonio area and are in need of some fast cash, stop by the W. Commerce Street TitleMax store or call us ...Location of This Business. 5545 Colerain Ave, Cincinnati, OH 45239. BBB File Opened: 2/1/2013. Years in Business: 34. Business Started: 1/1/1990. Business Incorporated:TitleMax. View full profile. Location of This Business. 1633 W Laskey Rd, Toledo, OH 43612-2915. Headquarters. BBB File Opened: 12/12/2014. Years in Business: 24.

Gun range stillwater ok.

Little caesars pizza carson city menu.

Posted on Dec 6, 2018. As long as you are within 30 days of your missed payment, you can pay off the pawn and get your car back. After that, TitleMax may work with you, but the title pawn would have the right to just keep the car. It's not fair, but unfortunately, this is what the law allows. If the payments are too high, then paying it off is ...Aug 15, 2016 · August 15, 2016 - 3:43 pm. Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook. A Nevada judge has delivered a blow to TitleMax, ordering an estimated 6,140 contracts to be voided with principal and ... Jul 24, 2023 · I had a title loan at a different store and Titlemax claimed their interest rate was lower so they bought out my title loan. Little did they tell me my entire $200 month payment was for interest ... Titlemax has 1 locations, listed below. ... and understand that the nature of complaints and a firm's responses to them are often more important than the number of complaints. ...Case Summary. On 09/10/2021 Patterson filed an Other lawsuit against TitleMax of California, Inc. This case was filed in California Courts of Appeal, Second Appellate District located in Statewide, California. The Judge overseeing this case is Escalante, Kristin. The case status is Pending - Other Pending.View customer complaints of Title Max - Corporate HQ, BBB helps resolve disputes with the services or products a business provides.March 31, 2023. 10:18 AM. 0. TMX Finance and its subsidiaries TitleMax, TitleBucks, and InstaLoan have collectively disclosed a data breach that exposed the personal data of 4,822,580 customers ...TitleMax of Georgia, Inc., and its parent company, TMX Finance LLC ("TMX"), petitioned the Alabama Supreme Court for a writ of mandamus to direct the Talladega Circuit Court to vacate its order denying their motion to dismiss them as parties to the underlying action commenced against them and others by Phallon Billingsley and to enter an order dismissing them from the action based on the trial ...The E. Fry Blvd. TitleMax store provides residents of the Sierra Vista area with title loans and personal loans. We are located next to Rodolfo's Taco Shop and Auto Zone. If you live in or around the greater Sierra Vista area and are in need of some fast cash, stop by the E. Fry Blvd. TitleMax store or call us today at (520) 458-5160 to get approved for a title loan or personal loan fast.Fire at Airbnb rental forced woman to climb out window, suit alleges. By Record staff reports | 26 days ago. HOUSTON - A lawsuit seeking more than $1 million in damages is alleging a woman was forced to exit through a second-story window because the Airbnb she was staying at caught fire.Oct 4, 2023 ... ... Title Max $15 million, alleging it violated the Military Lending Act. In an unrelated action, the Pennsylvania Attorney General sued Auto ... ….

TitleMax car and motorcycle title loans are available in 17 states. Unlike many other loan options, you don’t need a good credit score or a bank account to qualify for a title loan.In Georgia, borrowers looking to alleviate debt through Chapter 13 bankruptcy can’t escape their high-interest title pawns thanks to a legal loophole that TitleMax helped secure. by Margaret Coker [email protected] , Joel Jacobs/ProPublica and Mollie Simon/ProPublica July 13th, 2023 Why you can trust The Current. Twitter.A title loan is an easy way to get cash using your car title instead of your credit score. Your title loan size may be determined by the amount of cash you need, your vehicle’s value, and your ability to repay. TitleMax offers car title loans up to $10,000*, and we focus on getting you the most cash possible while keeping your payments ...McClairne filed this lawsuit against TitleMax on September 23, 2022, asserting a variety of claims including fraud, breach of contract, and violations of unspecified consumer rights. (Dkt. No. 1 at ¶ 5.1). McClairne amended his complaint on November 4, 2022, (Dkt. No. 9), and TitleMax moved to enforce the arbitration clause contained in the ...7380 S Eastern Ave Ste 126, Las Vegas, NV 89123-1552. Headquarters. BBB File Opened: 2/23/2012. Years in Business: 23. Business Started: 5/4/2000. Business Started Locally:0 complaints against Titlemax closed in last 3 years. Complaints Type of response; 0: Making a full refund, as the consumer requested: 0: Making a partial refund: 0: Agreed to make an adjustment: 0: Refusing to make an adjustment: 0: Refuse to adjust, relying on terms of agreement: 0:Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 protects employees from discrimination and harassment in the workplace. The EEOC filed the lawsuit in U.S. District Court for the District of South ...Car Title Loan Lawsuits Attorneys are now investigating lawsuits against predatory lenders across the United States, but especially in Utah and New Mexico. In some states, title loans are illegal ...TMX Finance is the parent company of TitleMax, TitleBucks, and InstaLoan – three popular services offering high-cost loans to people who typically do not have access to traditional sources of credit. ... Google to delete billions of web browsing data records to resolve lawsuit April 2nd, 2024 ‘Cybercrime organization’ stole customer and ...TitleMax of Delaware, Inc. | The ClassAction.org Newswire is a free resource for breaking class action lawsuit and settlement news, case updates and more. ... June 8, 2021 A lawsuit claims TitleMax charges loan customers excessive interest while attempting to skirt state usury statutes through a choice of law clause in its contracts. Titlemax lawsuit, Calling our dedicated New Mexico team at (505) 436-3561 and making a debit card payment over the phone. Visiting a MoneyGram® location to make a cash payment. PLEASE NOTE: Fees apply.*. Mailing a cashier's check or money order to TitleMax c/o New Mexico Team 2312 East Trinity Mills Road, Carrollton, TX 75006., More than two dozen car-tile lenders and brokers sued TitleMax over claims that the lending giant used illegal and unethical tactics to siphon off their customers. April 23, 2019 at 05:33 PM 1 ..., The class action lawsuit was filed on March 31, the same day TitleMax announced the data breach. It alleges the victims' personal information was compromised due to TMX's "negligent and/or ..., View full profile. Location of This Business. 4311 Fredericksburg Rd, Balcones Heights, TX 78201-1951. Email this Business. Headquarters. 5165 Emerald Pkwy Ste 100, Dublin, OH 43017-1063. BBB File ..., 5 Star Loans. Loans offered in all states except South Dakota, West Virginia, Vermont, and New York. Loan amounts between $2,600 to $20,000. Title loans and personal loans available. "A+" rated by the BBB. 5 Star Loans works with consumers to get auto title loans and personal loans ranging from $2,600 to $20,000., This organization is not BBB accredited. Check Cashing Services in Appleton, WI. See BBB rating, reviews, complaints, & more., Jan 18, 2023 ... A class of plaintiffs sued two TitleMax entities for entering into car-title loan transactions, often known as “payday loans,” at unlawful ..., Case Summary. On 09/10/2021 Patterson filed an Other lawsuit against TitleMax of California, Inc. This case was filed in California Courts of Appeal, Second Appellate District located in Statewide, California. The Judge overseeing this case is Escalante, Kristin. The case status is Pending - Other Pending., A loan company in Virginia accused of lending at illegally high interest rates reached a $44 million settlement Tuesday in a scheme that used affiliation with two Native American Tribes to evade st…, TitleMax to pay millions in lawsuits. Feb 27, 2023 11:45 PM EST. Rochelle Dean, Columbia, SC (WOLO) — TitleMax is in serious hot water with the government and the military., Titlemax repossessed and sold my vehicle are they required to provide information verifying what they sold the vehivle for. ... checks or "check by phone" because if they find a bank account the collector will be more likely recommend a lawsuit the their legal department. Get written confirmation of any payment plan the agency will accept., TitleMax Lawsuits. If you want to know just how unhappy consumers are with TitleMax, take a look at the number of complaints consumers have made online. Nowadays, most original creditors, credit card companies, etc. have arbitration clauses, which means that if you have a complaint against that company, you must file your claim in arbitration. ..., Feb 24, 2023 · The $15 million fine is the CFPB’s second ruling against the company. In 2016, the agency fined TitleMax $9 million after documenting deceptive practices in Georgia, Tennessee and Alabama, and ... , March 31, 2023. 10:18 AM. 0. TMX Finance and its subsidiaries TitleMax, TitleBucks, and InstaLoan have collectively disclosed a data breach that exposed the personal data of 4,822,580 customers ..., TitleMax operates more than 1,000 offices in 16 states, offering high-interest loans to consumers with their vehicles as collateral. Nevada law limits the length of such loans to 210 days., 12/05/2021. Business Response /* (1000, 5, 2021/10/12) */ AutoMoney regrets that the customer has had a negative experience with our company. An AutoMoney representative will be reaching out to ..., But on September 23, 2021, the Debtor timely filed a proof of claim on TitleMax's behalf. (Claim No. 4-1). The proof of claim indicated that the $3,700.00 claim was secured by the 2010 Ford Edge. (Claim No. 4-1, p. 2). The Debtor did not attach any supporting documentation to the proof of claim., TMX Finance, who owns TitleMax, TitleBucks and InstaLoan, exposed over 4.8 million customers' personal and financial information in a data breach. Attorneys working with ClassAction.org are pursuing mass arbitration claims against the lending company for data breach victims., The City files Criminal Complaints Against TitleMax. On May 30, 2019, after TitleMax had filed its petition, the City filed two criminal complaints against TitleMax in Travis County Municipal Court, alleging that the two loans that it had previously identified during its February 2019 audit violated the section 4-12-22(D) by exceeding the ..., Business Details. Headquarters. 15 Bull St Ste 200, Savannah, GA 31401-2686. Headquarters. 5165 Emerald Pkwy Ste 100, Dublin, OH 43017-1063. BBB File Opened: 1/28/2002. Years in Business: 37. , If you live in or around the greater Odessa area and are in need of some fast cash, stop by the East 8th St. TitleMax store or call us today at (432) 289-6497 to get approved for a title loan or personal loan fast! ... I have been since the remodel. Everything was great. Service was second to none. Catfish was fresh and delicious. No complaints ..., TitleMax, TitleBucks and InstaLoan suffered a data breach affecting nearly 5 million people. Here's what you should know, including potential legal action., TitleMax of Ohio, Inc. has 1 ... The Complaints and Customer Reviews shown on this profile include all complaints and reviews submitted about either the business headquarters or any of its ..., Titlemax / TMX Finance reviews & complaints. Titlemax / TMX Finance. 14039 Coit Rd, Dallas, TX, 75240, US. Learn how the rating is calculated 1 complaint. File a complaint Write a review. Website www.titlemax.com . Phone number +1 972 773 8722. Category Financing and Loans. Working hours Mon 9:00 am - 7:00 pm ..., TitleMax is a lending business, TitleBucks a car loans service, while InstaLoan is a personal loan service for people with poor credit scores. Issuing a notification to affected individuals, TMX ..., Savannah, Georgia (February 2023) TMX Finance LLC, also known as TitleMax (the "Company"), entered into an agreement with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau ("CFPB") addressing two limited and specific components of Company operations. The agreement addresses military lending and non-file-insurance practices. The solutions established will further support the high-quality service ..., TitleMax advertises interest rates of 9.9%, which isn't exactly low, but the way the loans are designed, the actual interest rate you pay could reach 179%., For a free case evaluationEmail Drew Brown [email protected]. CLICK HERE TO EMAIL – *Please be sure to include your direct telephone number in your email so we can call you back! [email protected]. Or Call. 336-478-6000., TitleMax San Bernardino. Title Loans. BBB Rating: NR (909) 862-2966. 2210 E Highland Ave Ste 119-121, Sn Bernrdno, CA 92404-4671. Get Auto Title Loans Fresno CA. Title Loans., The Highway 69 East TitleMax store provides residents of the Kansas City area with title secured loans and personal loans. We are located on the corner of Bryant Street, next door to McDonald's, and across the street from the fire station. If you live in or around the greater Kansas City area and are in need of some fast cash, stop by the ..., TitleMax Title Loans has 2 locations, ... BBB asks third parties who publish complaints, reviews and/or responses on this website to affirm that the information provided is accurate. However, BBB ..., A proposed class action lawsuit filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia on February 21, 2024 against TitleMax of Georgia, Inc. and TMX Finance LLC (together ..., The class action lawsuit was filed on March 31, the same day TitleMax announced the data breach. It alleges the victims’ personal information was compromised due to TMX’s “negligent and/or ...